Key problems in D2C that experimentation solves

For direct-to-consumer brands, data-driven testing is the real game-changer.

Part one of a three-part series.

“Half your ideas will fail… you need to verify and tweak your ideas until they actually deliver value for the customer.”

– Wyatt Thompson, Dollar Shave Club

Why D2C brands face unique challenges

Direct-to-consumer (D2C) brands thrive by forging direct relationships with customers—yet this also makes them vulnerable to every friction point along the user journey.

Even minor website hiccups, confusing checkout steps, or poorly timed promotions can cause prospective buyers to bounce or churn.

Experimentation helps identify these stumbling blocks and uncover the most effective solutions.

Get the guide: Optimize your D2C growth

Friction during first-time conversions

Many users abandon their carts at the first sign of inconvenience. Complex sign-up forms and confusing navigation are common culprits. By running A/B tests—like comparing a single-page form versus a multi-step process—D2C teams can pinpoint which layout yields higher sign-up and checkout completion rates.

Overlooked opportunities in product discovery

Large product catalogs can overwhelm shoppers if the site’s search or recommendation features aren’t optimized. Through experimentation, brands can test different algorithms (e.g., semantic vs. keyword-based) or surface trending bundles (“Complete the look”) to see which approach not only increases product visibility but also boosts average order value.

How experimentation offers solutions

Reinvesting resources into things that win

Experimentation helps D2C teams uncover surprisingly effective ideas and quickly shelve those that don’t work—leading to smarter resource allocation. Mad Rabbit, a tattoo aftercare D2C brand, tested a floating how-to video on their product pages:

"They saw an 8% lift in conversion and much longer session durations, so they rolled it out to all users."

Rent the Runway similarly discovered which aspects of their service drove the most value and invested heavily in behind-the-scenes logistics. This alignment of product, design, marketing, and growth teams around shared data is a hallmark of successful D2C experimentation.

Ultimately, experimentation is a growth engine. Small A/B test wins compound over time:

“Big doors swing on little hinges.”

All those little optimizations open big doors to better customer experiences and stronger business outcomes.

Personalizing the user journey

D2C brands serve diverse audiences, often scattered across regions with different shopping preferences. Localizing imagery, language, and even payment methods can lift conversion rates significantly. Experimenting with region-specific homepages or payment options (like Alipay in Asia) helps determine the best triggers for each market.

Boosting retention and decreasing churn

Getting a sale is only half the battle. Retention-focused experiments—like testing different recommendation frequencies or offering loyalty point accelerators—reveal what keeps customers engaged beyond their initial purchase.

For example, small tweaks to the timing or format of promotional emails can reduce churn and encourage repeat purchases within 28 days.

Reactivating dormant customers

Winning back inactive users is often cheaper than finding new ones. Targeted A/B tests around personalized win-back campaigns (“We saved your favorites!” vs. “Here’s 20% off if you come back”) can show which incentives rekindle interest. By gathering data on which message resonates best, D2C brands significantly improve their reactivation rates.

From friction to loyalty through experimentation

Systematic testing allows D2C teams to tackle their biggest hurdles—complex sign-ups, limited product exposure, and fluctuating retention—using precise, data-backed strategies.

Every experiment, whether it’s optimizing checkout forms or personalizing recommendations, helps solve core problems at scale. This ongoing commitment to experimentation ensures D2C brands remain agile, customer-centric, and poised to capitalize on every growth opportunity.

D2C experimentation guide

Get the complete picture. Download the D2C experimentation guide for real insights into the quantifiable wins that the leading D2C companies have earned.

Get the free guide