The secret thread between D2C companies

Why experimentation drives transformative growth.

Part three of a three-part series.

What makes some direct-to-consumer (D2C) brands stand out in crowded markets while others struggle to keep customers engaged?

After analyzing multiple D2C success stories, one unifying practice became clear: they treat experimentation and rigorous data analysis as the core engine for growth.

The power of ongoing testing goes beyond optimizing a single button color or discount banner. Instead, it enables brands to find precisely what resonates with customers at every turn, generating substantial gains in conversion, average order value, and long-term loyalty.

Get the guide: Optimize your D2C growth

Uncovering the hidden advantage of data-driven decisions

By continuously testing how customers interact with product pages, sign-up flows, or loyalty offers, D2C leaders uncover which features and strategies genuinely move the needle. For instance:

• Some discovered that focusing on simplified checkout fields measurably lifted first-time purchase rates.

• Others found that region-specific imagery and localized payment options turned curious browsers into repeat buyers at much higher rates than generic content could achieve.

These findings are not one-off wins. They accumulate over time—test by test—giving brands a dynamic view of what customers want.

“We used feature flags when introducing voice-ordering in our app… We increased the rollout slowly and analyzed user behavior.”

– Wyatt Thompson, Dollar Shave Club

How experimentation delivers substantial gains

Experimentation isn’t just about trying new ideas; it’s about confirming what really works before rolling it out across the business. Here are some of the standout benefits:

Higher conversions for first-time buyers

By running A/B tests on everything from pop-up messaging (“2,459 purchased today!” vs. “15% off your first purchase”) to form layouts (single-page vs. multi-step), some D2C brands cut cart abandonment rates significantly.

When each checkout flow element has been tested and validated, the resulting lift in first-time conversion can be substantial.

Improved product discovery and increased average order value

Large D2C catalogs can overwhelm shoppers—unless the site’s search and recommendation tools are optimized. Brands that tested different search algorithms (semantic vs. keyword-based) or experimented with “Complete the look” bundles saw more engagement with additional products.

The result: a noticeable uptick in average order value, often driven by more personalized, data-informed recommendations.

Stronger retention and reactivation strategies

Shortening the time between purchases relies on recommending the right products at the right intervals. Leading D2C brands fine-tune recommendation timing, frequency, and style—whether via in-app prompts or loyalty points. They also run specialized win-back campaigns for dormant customers, comparing incentives (“We saved your favorites!” vs. “Here’s 20% off”) to see which yields the biggest reactivation lift.

Over time, this iterative testing cuts churn and boosts overall lifetime value.

Why experimentation sets D2C leaders apart

Without testing, decisions rely on guesswork and intuition. Top-performing D2C companies treat each hypothesis—be it a new checkout step or a localized homepage—as an opportunity to learn about their audience. The data they gather, even from failed tests, provides direction that helps them pivot quickly and adapt.

While others make broad changes and hope for results, these brands refine every detail until they uncover what truly amplifies revenue and loyalty.

“Experimentation is valuable because it helps us verify our assumptions… Without experimentation, we’re just releasing into the wild.”

– Wyatt Thompson, Dollar Shave Club

The secret thread revealed

Experimentation is more than a best practice—it’s the foundation that underpins the success of leading D2C companies. The brands that invest in systematic testing and data-driven decisions see meaningful gains in conversions, average order value, and customer retention. It’s a process that compounds over time, giving these innovators an advantage that can be difficult for competitors to replicate.

By embracing this secret thread—relentless experimentation—D2C businesses can rise above market pressures and consistently deliver experiences that keep shoppers coming back.

D2C experimentation guide

Get the complete picture. Download the D2C experimentation guide for real insights into the quantifiable wins that the leading D2C companies have earned.

Get the free guide